Ebook Whatever Became of Sin?, by Karl Menninger
Whatever Became Of Sin?, By Karl Menninger As a matter of fact, publication is truly a window to the world. Also many people might not appreciate checking out books; the books will consistently give the precise info regarding truth, fiction, encounter, adventure, politic, religious beliefs, and also a lot more. We are here a site that gives compilations of publications greater than guide establishment. Why? We give you bunches of numbers of link to obtain the book Whatever Became Of Sin?, By Karl Menninger On is as you require this Whatever Became Of Sin?, By Karl Menninger You could find this publication quickly here.
Whatever Became of Sin?, by Karl Menninger
Ebook Whatever Became of Sin?, by Karl Menninger
Use the sophisticated technology that human develops today to find the book Whatever Became Of Sin?, By Karl Menninger quickly. Yet initially, we will certainly ask you, just how much do you love to read a book Whatever Became Of Sin?, By Karl Menninger Does it consistently until coating? Wherefore does that book read? Well, if you truly enjoy reading, aim to review the Whatever Became Of Sin?, By Karl Menninger as one of your reading compilation. If you just read guide based on need at the time as well as unfinished, you have to aim to like reading Whatever Became Of Sin?, By Karl Menninger initially.
Also the price of a book Whatever Became Of Sin?, By Karl Menninger is so cost effective; numerous people are actually thrifty to reserve their cash to acquire guides. The other factors are that they really feel bad and have no time at all to head to guide company to look guide Whatever Became Of Sin?, By Karl Menninger to review. Well, this is modern-day age; numerous publications can be got quickly. As this Whatever Became Of Sin?, By Karl Menninger and also much more e-books, they can be entered extremely fast methods. You will not have to go outside to obtain this e-book Whatever Became Of Sin?, By Karl Menninger
By seeing this web page, you have done the best gazing point. This is your beginning to pick the publication Whatever Became Of Sin?, By Karl Menninger that you want. There are bunches of referred e-books to check out. When you intend to obtain this Whatever Became Of Sin?, By Karl Menninger as your book reading, you could click the link web page to download and install Whatever Became Of Sin?, By Karl Menninger In couple of time, you have possessed your referred books as your own.
As a result of this book Whatever Became Of Sin?, By Karl Menninger is offered by online, it will reduce you not to print it. you could obtain the soft data of this Whatever Became Of Sin?, By Karl Menninger to save in your computer system, gadget, as well as more tools. It relies on your willingness where and where you will read Whatever Became Of Sin?, By Karl Menninger One that you should consistently keep in mind is that reading e-book Whatever Became Of Sin?, By Karl Menninger will never finish. You will certainly have eager to check out other e-book after completing an e-book, as well as it's continually.
- Sales Rank: #2050621 in Books
- Published on: 1974
- Binding: Hardcover
Most helpful customer reviews
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful.
THE FAMED PSYCHIATRIST SUGGESTS BRINGING BACK THE CONCEPT OF "SIN" AND RESPONSIBILITY
By Steven H Propp
Karl Augustus Menninger (1893-1990) was an American psychiatrist and a member of the Menninger family of psychiatrists who founded the Menninger Foundation and the Menninger Clinic in Topeka, Kansas. He wrote many books, such as Man Against Himself, Love Against Hate, The human mind, etc. [NOTE: page numbers below refer to the 242-page hardcover edition.]
He wrote in this 1973 book, "In all of the laments and reproaches made by our seers and prophets, one misses any mention of 'sin,' a word which used to be a veritable watchword of prophets. It was a word once in everyone's mind but now rarely if every heard. Does that mean that no sin is involved in all our troubles---sin with an 'I' in the middle? Is no one any longer guilty of anything? Guilty perhaps of a sin that could be repented of or atoned for?... Anxiety and depression we all acknowledge, and even vague guilt feelings; but has no one committed any sins? Where, indeed, did sin go? What became of it?" (Pg. 13) He explains, "'What WAS the sin that no longer exists?' ... I have in mind behavior that violates the moral code or the individual conscience or both; behavior which pains or harms or destroys my neighbor---or me, myself." (Pg. 17) He adds, "although it has disappeared from serious use in our workaday vocabularies, perhaps it has not gone from the back of our minds. We shall see." (Pg. 24)
He suggests, "I believe there is 'sin' which is expressed in ways which cannot be subsumed under verbal artifacts such as 'crime,' 'disease,' 'delinquency,' 'deviancy.' There IS immorality; there IS unethical behavior; there IS wrongdoing. And I hope to show that there is usefulness in retaining the concept, and indeed the word, SIN, which now shows some signs of returning to public acceptance. I would like to help this trend along." (Pg. 46)
He argues, "The use of diagnostic labels in a pejorative way is a sin of which I have myself been guilty. I began to see how much harm is caused and consequently I have discontinued it. Dr. Thomas Szasz of New York State goes even further than I; he will not even concede the existence of ANY 'mental illness.' He believes this to be a mythical, political, and damaging designation. I have myself proposed that we speak rather of 'Personality Dysorganization' of various degrees rather than 'mental disease,' psychosis, neurosis, and the like." (Pg. 171)
He asserts, "The assumption that there is sin... implies both a possibility and an obligation for intervention. Presumably something is possible which can be reparative, corrective, meliorative, and that something involves me and mercy---we want them, too. But we want to think we can help ourselves and our fellows if only a modicum. Hence sin is the only hopeful view... Therefore I say that the consequence of my proposal would not be more depression, but less. If the concept of personal responsibility and answerability for ourselves and for others were to return to common acceptance, hope would return to the world with it!" (Pg. 188) He concludes, "If we believe in sin---as I do---we believe in our personal responsibility for trying to correct it, and thereby saving ourselves and our world." (Pg. 220)
Despite the lapse of 40 years since this book was written, Menninger's proposal for a return to responsibility and the corresponding possibility of redemption still have a strong resonance with the modern temperament, I would think.
Whatever Became of Sin?, by Karl Menninger PDF
Whatever Became of Sin?, by Karl Menninger EPub
Whatever Became of Sin?, by Karl Menninger Doc
Whatever Became of Sin?, by Karl Menninger iBooks
Whatever Became of Sin?, by Karl Menninger rtf
Whatever Became of Sin?, by Karl Menninger Mobipocket
Whatever Became of Sin?, by Karl Menninger Kindle
No comments:
Post a Comment